Strategic vs Tactical Allocation

A comprehensive guide on the differences between strategic and tactical asset allocation, and how to combine them effectively.

TL; DR

• Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA) is a long-term investment strategy based on risk tolerance, investment horizon, and financial goals.

• Tactical Asset Allocation (TAA) is a dynamic strategy that adjusts the asset mix in response to short-term market conditions to enhance returns or manage risk.

• SAA involves setting a fixed asset allocation and periodically rebalancing, while TAA involves market timing and flexibility.

• Investors can combine SAA and TAA by establishing a base SAA and making short-term tactical adjustments within set ranges.

---

Strategic Asset Allocation (SAA)

Strategic Asset Allocation is a long-term investment strategy that establishes an ideal mix of asset classes in line with an investor's risk tolerance, investment horizon, and financial goals. It is based on the Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT), which suggests that it is possible to design an 'efficient frontier' of optimal portfolios offering the maximum possible expected return for a given level of risk.

Key Principles of SAA

• Diversification: Spreading investments across various asset classes to reduce risk.

• Risk Tolerance: Understanding the investor's capacity to endure market volatility.

• Investment Horizon: Aligning the asset mix with the time frame for investment goals.

• Rebalancing: Periodically adjusting the portfolio to maintain the original asset allocation.

Expand for more on Rebalancing

Rebalancing involves selling assets that have increased in proportion due to market movements and buying those that have decreased to return to the original asset allocation. This process helps in maintaining the risk level consistent with the investor's risk profile.

SAA Implementation Steps

1. Determine Objectives: Define clear and measurable investment goals.

2. Assess Risk Tolerance: Evaluate how much risk the investor is willing to take.

3. Choose Asset Classes: Select a mix of equities, bonds, cash, and alternative investments.

4. Set Target Allocations: Decide the percentage of each asset class in the portfolio.

5. Construct the Portfolio: Purchase the chosen investments in the defined proportions.

6. Monitor and Rebalance: Regularly review and adjust the portfolio to maintain the target allocation.

Tactical Asset Allocation (TAA)

Tactical Asset Allocation is a more dynamic investment strategy that allows for short-term adjustments to the asset mix in response to market conditions or economic forecasts. TAA aims to capitalize on market inefficiencies or trends to enhance returns or manage risk.

Key Principles of TAA

• Market Timing: Making investment decisions based on expected market movements.

• Asset Selection: Choosing specific securities within an asset class to outperform the market.

• Flexibility: Adjusting the asset allocation as opportunities or risks arise.

Expand for more on Market Timing

Market timing is the strategy of making buy or sell decisions of financial assets by attempting to predict future market price movements. This approach is often criticized for its difficulty and the risk of missing out on market rallies or not avoiding downturns as anticipated.

TAA Implementation Steps

1. Market Analysis: Study economic indicators, market trends, and geopolitical events.

2. Identify Opportunities: Look for mispriced assets or sectors poised for growth.

3. Adjust Allocations: Temporarily overweight or underweight certain asset classes.

4. Execute Trades: Act on the tactical decisions by buying or selling assets.

5. Monitor Outcomes: Closely track the performance of the tactical moves.

6. Return to SAA: Revert to the strategic asset allocation when appropriate.

Combining SAA and TAA

Investors can combine both SAA and TAA to benefit from the stability of a long-term strategy while still taking advantage of short-term market opportunities. This hybrid approach requires a disciplined framework to ensure that tactical deviations do not significantly alter the strategic risk profile of the portfolio.

Steps to Integrate SAA and TAA

1. Establish a Base SAA: Define a long-term strategic asset allocation.

2. Set Tactical Ranges: Determine acceptable ranges for temporary deviations.

3. Implement Tactical Decisions: Make short-term adjustments within the set ranges.

4. Monitor and Adjust: Regularly review both strategic and tactical allocations.

5. Rebalance: Realign the portfolio to the strategic asset allocation periodically.

By understanding and applying the principles of SAA and TAA, investors can create a robust framework for managing their portfolios through different market conditions. The key is to maintain a balance between the discipline of a long-term strategy and the flexibility to adapt to short-term market changes.